I received my SW-3B QRP CW transceiver several days ago and would like to offer a few details to others who may be interested. A manual is available online here.
The SW-3B has some obvious similarities to KD1JV's MTR-3B - and some significant differences. These differences, in my opinion, distinguish it from being a clone of the MTR-3B - otherwise I would not have bought one.
I have built and owned many of Steve KD1JV's fine rigs in the past, including an MTR-3B, which I sold when I bought a KX2. It was (and is!) a great radio for its intended purpose and I wanted to see how the SW-3B compared.
Similarities of the two radios:
- Wide operating voltage range (MTR-3B = 6-12V; SW-3B = 8-15V)
- 20/30/40-meter operation
- Built-in keyer
- Almost identical size, shape and weight (MTR-3B = 4.5 oz; SW-3B = 6.4 oz)
The SW-3B has these additional features, not present in the MTR-3B:
- 8 frequency memories for each band
- Dual mode receive (CW/SSB) with fixed bandwidths for each mode (400Hz/2kHz)
- Automatic CQing
- Variable rate rotary tuning
- LCD backlight
- Separate RF and AF gain controls
- Significantly lower in price ($188 vs. $350)
The radio arrived well-packed from China 19 days after ordering it. Prior to that, Dale BA4TB was quick to answer a couple of emails from me regarding questions on the radio and provided a tracking number when it was sent.
Radio includes BNC-SO-239 adapter, DC power cord & printed manual |
Prior to putting the SW-3B on the air I hooked it up to my variable voltage power supply, a WM-2 QRP wattmeter and a dummy load to take readings of power out vs. DC voltage in on the three bands. Receive current draw at 13.8V is 37 mA with the backlight off, 43 mA with the light on. The backlight can be configured as always off, always on or "Automatic", turning on when a button of VFO dial is used and then turning off after a few seconds.
Power out & TX current for various input voltages |
After these measurements it was time to put the rig on the air. LZ1WR was calling CQ on 20m. He was copied and worked with no problem. A few hours later I heard CT9/DL3YM working split, also on 20m. This gave me an opportunity to use the SW-3B's XIT function. I tuned to the station's transmit frequency, then enabled XIT and tuned about 1.3 kHz higher and started calling. After three tries, CT9/DL3YM was in the log.
Into dummy load with 13.8V DC input |
Another way to do this would be to tune to the pile-up's frequency, then enable RIT and tune down to the DX station's transmit frequency in order to hear him and know when to call. Each method is sort of a "poor man's VFO-B" for simple rigs that don't have dual VFO's but do have either a RIT or XIT or, in the SW-3B's case - both. The LCD display on the SW-3B indicates how far away you are with either function - in 100 Hz steps for XIT and in 10 Hz steps for RIT.
After logging these stations I entered my callsign into the rig's memory to enable automatic CQing. A push of the "CQ" button initiates a 2X2 CQ (CQ CQ de callsign callsign K) with a push of the button.
The KEY jack detects whether a straight key or paddles are plugged in to the rig. With paddles, the internal keyer is automatically enabled. Keyer speed is set via a long press of the CQ button and a press of either the dit or dah side of the paddles. This setting (and the entered callsign) is saved into memory so that the rig's keyer comes up at that speed the next time the radio is turned on.
Four trim caps used to maximize received signal (2 for 20m, 1 each on 30 & 40). Variable resistor (below toroid, top center) adjusts displayed voltage reading. |
The internal keyer is functional and works well but I quickly came to prefer my external keyer so that I could more quickly change speeds if necessary.
The sidetone frequency is fixed at 600 Hz. Its volume is fixed relative to background audio and tracks it with the AF Gain control.
Bands are selected by what looks to be two distinct 3-position switches but it is actually one switch - the two are physically linked together so that only one need be moved; the other moves in step with it. A nice touch would have been to label the switch positions with the bands they refer to but as it is, Position 1 is 40 meters, 2 is 30m and 3 is 20m.
Each band has up to 8 frequency/mode memories. Upon each power-up, the SW-3B will be in memory mode. Turning the tuning dial cycles it through the memories for that band. A press of the M/V/SAVE button puts the rig into VFO mode on the chosen memory's frequency.
CW Ops mini-Test this morning (14 Aug 2019) |
Forty minutes of participation in this morning's CW Ops CWT sprint resulted in 31 contacts, all easily made, including a DX contact (DK9PY). The speed of most exchanges was about 30 wpm with the rig being keyed by N3FJP's software made for this contest. I operated both search-and-pounce and ran a freq for a while. No problems at all with the rig at that speed though a narrower (than 400 Hz) filter would have been beneficial. But, of course, this is not meant to be a contest rig and I'm very happy with its performance.
Suggestions for improvement:
1) The sequence of how the cursor moves when changing the tuning steps. As it is:
so to go from start-up to the 100 Hz digit, I have to press the button 4 times, two of which are for the same step size. This makes no sense and neither do the remaining sequences.
2)
Have the rig power up in the state last used, either Memory or VFO - not always in the Memory state.
These are minor issues that I believe could be fixed with firmware changes. They don't detract from the rig's usefulness, especially in the area for which it was designed - as a small, very lightweight 3-band rig that puts out a full "QRP gallon".
.
.
Thanks for the suggestions,we will get these fixed.
ReplyDelete73,
Dale BA4TB
I ended up operating all three sessions of the CWT contest with the SW-3B, using my Hardrock-50 part of the time. Lots of fun.
ReplyDeleteThe 9 VDC 30m power out seems to have dropped a most-significant digit. Is it supposed to be 3.5 W, rather than .5 W?
ReplyDeleteI was surprised at that too but 0.5W is correct.
DeleteThanks! I assume the label "Phone" in the lower right corners means "Headphones". Do stereo headphones use both L&R channels? Do mono headphones work ok?
ReplyDeleteHow is the receiver portion of the rig? Selectivity?
Is there a CW filter built in? If so how narrow is it?
At $188 it is very attractive!
https://ba4tb.qth.com/product/sw-3b-qrp-cw-transceiver/
Tony W1AJO
Newnan, GA
Tony, I am just seeing this email trail. Was there any import duty with the radio coming from China? Also, can you try that URL again. I am not able to access it in Texas. AT&T wireless has it blocked.
DeleteYes, it is a stereo headphone jack so, with mono headphones, the sound would go to both sides of the phones. CW bandwidth is 400 Hz.
ReplyDelete73 - John
Gosh I wished I read this earlier.. I just ordered the HB-1B..
ReplyDeleteI got mine recently, it took 19 days. I am REALLY happy with it, so far.
ReplyDeleteone suggestion would be: rather than being able to select CW-CWR-USB-LSB, those same button presses could toggle between 200, 600, 800, 1.5kHz CW filters.
ReplyDeleteit would also be nice for the CQ function to have a repeat function, with a programmable pause. And to be able to record at least one entire message.
The CW filters would add to the complexity of the circuit and possibly the size of the radio,but the other changes could be done in firmware.
Deleteno swr meter?
ReplyDeleteI am happy with my MTR3B from LNR. My friend bought this chinese radio and it arrived defective. However, add a 9v battery and go make some QSO
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your findings ...great report! So is the T/R relays or diode? How much of delay between T-R? Adjustable if relay? Noisy? I presume not QSK for this size/price, right? TU de wGOAT
ReplyDeleteHello Steve, there are no relays - it is solid state keying. The T/R delay is so short as to be unnoticeable. I can't receive between dots but, even at 30 wpm, I won't miss anything on receive no matter how quickly the other station responds when I finish sending. I'm going to try to make a video tonight (0300-0400Z) during the CWT Sprint, showing how it operates on fast CW. It may take me a day or two to get the video posted.
Deleteif I can stay up, I'll be keying with a TBFB cootie, and will only be cranking out about 28 wpm.
ReplyDeleteK3ESE
Thanks for a great review John. But it begs the question of why any modern producer of such transceivers should still be making such basic design errors!
ReplyDeleteYes, that is a good question, especially the issue of cursor sequencing to change the tuning step.
DeleteI have 2 of the 4 band HB1B radios and 2 of the 2 band TEN-TEC used to sell.
ReplyDeleteAlso have the 3 band that was the first China rig out.
I think the minor bugs should be fixed
73 BOB AF2DX
I've just discovered your post. Thanks! Is it possible to turn down the RF output, for QRPp?
ReplyDeleteNot that I know of - you might try asking Dale BA4TB.
DeleteHi just found your review. Can you tell me the bandwidth on 40m. I was thinking about using it for cross mode net check in on 7.283. 73 de KF7VUT
ReplyDeleteLate to the party, but
ReplyDeletePower out is dependent on the input voltage. To reduce power, lower input voltage.
The HB-1A/HB-1B/HS-1A/HS-1B/MFJ-9200 are also set up to feed the input voltage to the PA transistor - which drives output power.
Thanks for the detailed review.
72 Don//KL7KN
John,
ReplyDeleteI'm buiding and testing several different QRP transmitters. Does your SW-3b really use a C2078 as the power amp? - and if so, how much of a heat sink does it have? I like the design as shown on the Venus website but want to make sure that is what is used. On their SSB unit, they use a IRF510 with adjustible bias, as you probably know. I want a QRP pa to produce enough power to drive a QRPlabs 50 watt cw amp.
Hello Jack,
DeleteI sold my SW-3B a few months ago so I can't answer your question. Dale BA4TB might be willing to give you an answer.
73 - John
Why did you sold it?
ReplyDeleteI was using the mcHF at the time and never used the SW-3B.
ReplyDeleteHello, I recived my SW-3B. I know that you have sold the rig, but maybe other want to know some info:
ReplyDeletePout: 7V - 1, 0.7, 0.5W (40, 30 and 20m band). At 8V: 1.7,1.4,4.4. At 9V 2.9, 3.2, 4.4. At 11V: 4.6,4.6,5.9. At 12.5V: 5.9,5.5, 6.9. Tested with oscilloscope and on 50 dummy load